A government inspector has dismissed an appeal against an order to reinstall 28 windows removed from a historic former Lancaster bar and hotel.
The inspector ruled in favour of Lancaster City Council, who successfully defended an appeal against an enforcement notice at the former Alexandra Hotel building on Penny Street, at the gateway to the city centre. The building, which is Grade II listed and was built in 1902 and was most recently home to a Revolution bar, has deteriorated in recent years following the unauthorised removal of windows which has exposed the structure to the elements.
The council served a Listed Building Enforcement Notice in Spring 2023, requiring all of the original windows to be reinstated and any necessary repairs to be carried out. The owner subsequently appealed the notice. A planning inspector has now dismissed the appeal and has upheld the council’s enforcement notice in its entirety. In making this decision, the inspector concluded that the timber windows were “intrinsic features” of the building’s overall character.
The appeal was made by Zubeir Mister of 107 Penny Street Ltd.
Planning inspector Thomas Shields' report, published last month, said the appeal was made on several grounds, including one that "challenges the listing of a building on the basis that the building is not of special architectural or historic interest".
This was dismissed, as the inspector said "there can be no doubt that the building known as the Alexandra Hotel is a listed building given that it is listed in Grade II in the statutory list compiled or approved by the Secretary of State".
The report went on to say: "The removal of the windows has been carried out without the benefit of listed building consent. The appellant must show therefore that the works do not affect the building’s character as a building of special architectural or historic interest.
"I consider the windows are intrinsic features to the listed building’s overall character. Consequently, their removal undoubtedly affects the character of the listed building.
“The appellant states that existing timber sash windows are in such poor condition they pose a considerable risk to the public of falling debris, as was the case at first floor (bay window).
"However, other than this statement no substantive evidence has been put forward to support the appellant’s assertion that the works were the minimum immediately necessary in terms of being essential and urgent for public safety, such that other works of repair or temporary support would not have been practicable."
The report also says the appeal was made on grounds that "the requirements of the notice exceed what is necessary for restoring the building to its condition before the works were carried out".
However, Mr Shields said: "The steps required to reinstate the 28 windows that have been removed clearly go no further, or place any extra burden on the appellant, other than to reverse the works that have been undertaken. As such, they do not exceed what is necessary for restoring the building to its condition before the works were carried out."
The council's Listed Building Enforcement Notice said the removal of eight timber single-glazed sliding sash windows from the first floor, 19 timber single-glazed sliding sash windows from the second floor and one fixed timber framed single-glazed window from the second floor, were against regulations. They have ordered for the windows to be reinstated, any damage since their removal be repaired, and for the windows to be painted.
The building’s owners now must comply with the terms of the enforcement notice or face the prospect of prosecution, said the council. The notice gives three months for the work to be completed, and this begins from the date of the inspector’s decision (February 16 2024).
Here is the building pictured on March 1 2024
Councillor Phillip Black, leader of Lancaster City Council, said: “The Alexandra Hotel forms part of a historic gateway into the city of Lancaster. It is a building that is valued highly by its residents and one that council officers will continue to strive to protect from inappropriate work.
“The planning inspector’s appeal decision is a welcome development in this case. The decision vindicates the city council in pursuing enforcement action. We would now urge the owner to comply with the notice as prescribed by the planning inspector.”
A spokesperson for local campaigning group Lancaster Civic Vision said: "Clearly as it stands the building is in a dangerous state and has been causing concerns to residents during the winter’s high winds and heavy rains, and Lancaster Civic Vision welcomes this ruling and opportunity to safeguard this historic building.
"This area is looking forward to Eden Project Morecambe opening in the near future at which time the Lancaster and Morecambe District will be welcoming an estimated one million visitors per year, all of whom we hope will be impressed enough with our area to stay beyond their Eden visit and perhaps wish to return again.
"It is therefore vital that the entrances and road approaches, as well as parking and rail facilities, are brought to the highest order possible to give a good impression and welcoming feel to these new visitors.
"It is an old and wise saying that states “you never get a second chance to make a first impression."
Located at 107 Penny Street, the building was built in 1902 as the Alexandra Hotel, and was most recently home to a Revolution bar, which closed in 2014, and prior to that, The Alex pub and nightspot, and The Catholic Social Club.
Read more: Council demands action to safeguard historic building at gateway to Lancaster - Beyond Radio
Guys Thatched Hamlet closes suddenly after 46 years
Teenager spared jail for causing death of newborn child in Morecambe
Morecambe Town Council agrees budget and 2.46 per cent rise in Council tax share
Builders of new Lancaster housing development offer £2k cash pot to community groups
Lancaster centre welcomes mayor for opening of new community kitchen
Lancaster shop to close as high street gaming chain faces administration
Jim Bentley returns for second spell as Morecambe FC manager
Ashvir Singh Johal’s reign as Morecambe manager comes to an end
Lancaster writer's ghost story of Morecambe to be voiced by acting legend on Radio 4
Change of name announced for popular Morecambe bar
Opening announced for new Morecambe bistro inside former post office
Health watchdog report shows improvements to services at Royal Lancaster Infirmary
LISTEN: How Leo's Gym is making a difference in memory of young Morecambe boxer
LISTEN: Lancaster set to celebrate Chinese New Year
Lancaster’s Vue Cinema under new ownership
Lancaster city centre car park to close ahead of "catalyst for the development of the Canal Quarter"
Crews tackle commercial building fire in Lancaster
Heritage plaque to mark first Lancaster University site and Gillow factory
Heysham men appear in court in connection with death of cyclist in Morecambe
Fundraiser launched for Heysham family who lost everything in house fire
