Plans for 25 bungalows for over 55s in a village near Lancaster have been given the go-ahead.
The new housing in fields near Hawthorn Avenue at Brookhouse was granted planning permission on Monday.
Residents spoke out against the proposals at a meeting held at Morecambe Town Hall, worried that the development could cause flooding and extra traffic, and said they felt there was unsuitable access to the land, and the scheme would cause potential damage to the environment.
But council officers recommended the scheme should be approved due to a housing shortfall in the Lancaster district.
"Whilst there are adverse impacts arising from the development, and a small degree of conflict with some policies within the Development Plan, these impacts are not considered to significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits of the proposal, namely, housing," said a council report.
Most councillors on the Lancaster City Council planning regulatory committee agreed.
Eight of the committee members - Councillors Cleet, King, Lenox, Knight, Thomas, Hartley, Tyldesley and Guilding - voted in favour of the scheme.
Councillors Redfern, Brookes, Hamilton-Cox and Budden abstained.
Councillor Tim Hamilton-Cox, of the Greens, said: "We should be looking at other land that is available and directing development to there.
"This is not what we would want to approve in usual circumstances."
But Councillor Colin Hartley, of Labour, said: "All the best sites have gone and have been built on.
"All planning applications have problems with them. We do desperately need houses for more mature members of the population."
The application by Applethwaite Homes was given the go-ahead subject to several conditions.
You can read the full planning report here.
The land is situated in the Forest of Bowland Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONB) but councillors were told there had been no comments received from the AONB Partnership.
Lancaster-Morecambe train services cancelled amid heavy rain warnings
Pair jailed for violent attack on man in Lancaster street
Panjab Warriors interview: "Morecambe FC will never be in danger while we are owners."
Canal charity gets the ‘hump’ as Lancaster Canal bridges suffer more collision damage
Lancaster wills company donates thousands to help local community groups making a difference
Morecambe Bay Curriculum wins top award
Lancaster film director's latest action movie now showing in UK cinemas
Appeal after Jack Russell dog found collapsed in Lancaster
Lancaster food companies announced as finalists in new Taste Lancashire Producer Awards
New student apartments block opens in Lancaster
Former BBC reporter and ex-Heysham shipping chief launch popular maritime podcast
Lancaster children get life-saving advice at 'Crucial Crew' water safety event
Crews tackle house fire in Heysham
Police appeal after 20 motorbike thefts in 30 days in Lancaster and Morecambe area
Truck driver jailed for causing death of six-year-old Lancaster girl
Former Morecambe Football Club co-chairmen break silence after shock resignation from board
Royal Lancaster Infirmary ward closed to visitors due to norovirus outbreak
Morecambe Football Club stalwarts resign from board
Heysham coffee shop couple take over Morecambe craft ale bar
Morecambe seafront cafe reopens
